Written By: Zack Harris

When it comes to fly fishing for carp, selecting the right fly is essential for success. Carp can be finicky, but with the right patterns, you’ll increase your chances of landing these powerful fish. Zack Harris, an experienced fly fisherman, has narrowed down his top three carp flies that have consistently proven effective. In this guide, Zack breaks down why these flies work so well and how they can help you up your carp fishing game.

Egan’s Headstand

The first fly that has brought me a ton of success is Egan’s Headstand. This pattern can be tied in different variations, but the commercially available version is lightweight and sinks quickly, making it a great choice for beginners and seasoned anglers alike. One reason it’s so effective is its ability to mimic a variety of nymphs, while also resembling a small crayfish. This versatility allows you to fish with just a few Headstands and confidently match the local forage. The lightweight design also lets you cast it with minimal splash, giving you the stealth needed to approach carp without spooking them. Egan’s Headstand is hands down the fly that’s landed me the majority of my carp.

Scarpion

Another must-have in your carp fly box is the Scarpion, created by Chase Smith. This fly is designed to ride hook-up, which means less chance of snagging on the bottom. It’s incredibly buggy and hits the water softly, preventing you from scaring away the fish. Like the Headstand, the Scarpion mimics both crayfish and larger aquatic insects, making it another highly versatile option when fly fishing for carp

Detroit Mop City

Lastly, Detroit Mop City by Daryl Eakins is an excellent choice for carp, especially in low-visibility conditions. This fly imitates a grub or dragonfly nymph and features a larger profile, making it easier for both the fish and the angler to spot. When fly fishing for carp, sometimes the fish aren’t picky, and this fly’s size and color give you an edge in murkier waters. The Detroit Mop City is perfect for situations where you need a larger, more visible presentation.

In carp fishing, versatility is key. With Zack Harris' top three fly choices – Egan’s Headstand, the Scarpion, and Detroit Mop City – you’ll be well-prepared to tackle any carp fishing situation. Remember, success in fly fishing for carp isn’t just about having the perfect fly; it’s about understanding how to present it and match it to the local conditions.